For all the work I have done with football players for the past year and a half, you would think that I would know better than to underestimate them. My post this past September, when they suffered their first loss of the season, emphasized their grit and resilience. Over the years, and as I have often posted on this blog, I've had a number of players in my classes and I have seen what they can do there, too.
But on Thursday, in my medieval art class, in which twenty players on the McDaniel College Green Terror football team are enrolled, my faith wavered. We were starting a short, two-day Reacting game, in which the students must decide about the role of images in the Byzantine church. It is my Byzantine Iconoclasm game that I have successfully used in the past. But on Thursday, I was not sure. Part of the reason was that I received two emails from different players on Wednesday night asking, "Are we starting that game/debate tomorrow?" Not reassuring.
When we got to class, I gave everyone about 15 minutes to get ready in their groups (Reacting games are made up of factions, or teams, and indeterminates who are not sure what they think about the issues and ask a lot of questions. You can read more about Reacting to the Past here). After that 15 minutes, I called everyone back to the classroom (some use the hallway for meetings). I took my place at the back of the room, because the students run the show in a Reacting class. The football player I cast as the Patriarch Nikephoros rose, walked to the podium, and welcomed everyone to the council and opened debate.
Without hesitation, students came to the podium to make speeches. There were lots of questions. And two football players, shown here, went at it, debating each other very seriously. It was a fantastic moment as a professor. I took the picture below to send to their Coach to show them his players in action.
I do not forget that I have 10 other students not on the team, a few of whom are in this picture, too. And they were ready and spoke that day, too. The mix of students is great and I have been very mindful of being sure to mix the class up at all times.
I will admit that it is really easy to think that the football players will not read, prepare, or get ready for class. I am working with a few students who are struggling in some of their classes. Yet they do care very much about their education and their studies. A colleague of mine ran a focus group with eight players and the findings will form the beginning of a new study of mine to find ways to support these students more effectively.
Reacting works with football players. Reacting to the Past works with many students. But with football players, it's something else. The competition, the debating - somehow it fires them up. At the end of the class on Thursday, several players said to me, "I am going to have a speech on Tuesday! Just wait!" They don't usually say things like that about a class that is five days away.
We play another Reacting game about the Crusades later this semester. I will try not to underestimate them again.
7 thoughts on “Underestimated”
Sorry, couldn't find the "Like" button, so my thumbs up should be larger than that!
I didn't even know you could do that so that is cool, Jim! It was really a great day. Now let's hope with all these accolades that tomorrow (Tuesday) really is as good a day as last Thursday!
You found a way to tap into their competitive spirit via education, however, I would state that your belief in them along with your encouragement is where it all began. You set a standard and made them aware of it and they competed in the classroom as if they were on the field.
I really appreciate this comment, which for some reason I am only seeing now! I really want to find out more about the space between encouraging them on the field helps support the classroom learning. I feel like there is so much that I want to quantify/qualify about what is happening so that it can be replicated by others.
I am laughing because sometimes allowing humans to be humans is not quantifiable.
Happy to discuss with you at some point.
Author Gretchen McKay, thank you for this post. Its very inspiring.